One 96% Happy Island


aruba_facebook.png


Introduction

The image and slogan of Aruba is "One Happy Island". Our research aim was to test how happy the island really is.

Research Question: To what extent can Aruba be considered a happy island? What are the issues of it? More generally we tried to identify methods of studying a country through facebook.

"I'm going to Aruba!" Facebook Status Sentiment Analysis

On the basis of Facebook status updates we aimed to identify the sentiment of the Arubian Facebook sphere.

Method

We coded 1000 of 3000 Facebook status updates, using the keyword "Aruba". The software we used to collect and code the data was DiscoverText. The updates were coded as positive/neutral/negative. The remaining 2000 updates classified automatically. Unfortunately the classifier did not work, with a large proportion (60%+) of the items automatically classified as negative being wrong.

The negative status updates found were again categorized to find Arubian issues debated on Facebook.

Findings

"I'm at the airport." Tweet Sentiment Analysis

On the basis of Tweets we aimed to identify the sentiment of the Arubian Twitter sphere.

Method

We coded 1000 of 3000 tweets, collected over a period of two days using the keyword "Aruba". The software we used to collect and code the data was DiscoverText. The tweets were coded as positive/neutral/negative. The remaining 2000 tweets classified automatically. Unfortunately the classifier did not work, with a large proportion (60%+) of the items automatically classified as negative being wrong.

The negative tweets found were again categorized to find Arubian issues debated on Twitter.

Findings

"If a thousand people like this page..." Facebook Group and Page Analysis

Following the most popular (according to Google) Facebook pages and groups we aimed to identify the relevant debates in the Arubian Facebook sphere.

Method

We coded 500 facebook pages. The pages were selected using the Google Scraper. The pages are classified by the following categories: business, hospitality, tourism, culture, politics/government, education, sports and activity, social/charity, online community, Off-topic

We coded 500 facebook groups. The groups were selected using the Google Scraper. The pages are classified by same categories used for the pages.

Twenty pages with the most likes on Facebook were taken to colorcode them by category.

Findings

Facebook_aruba_groups_categorized.png

Facebook_Aruba_pages_categories.png

Mapping the outlines of the Discourse About Aruba on Facebook

Looking for issues related to Aruba on Facebook (following a grounded approach), we run into two big topics: 1) The case of Natalee Holloway and her (purported) killer Joran Van Der Sloot; 2) Virtual petitions for boycotting Aruba, mainly due to the Holloway case.

We split the topics in order to obtain four main topics suitable for big used heuristics categories: ‘Holloway’, ’Van Der Slot’, ‘Boycott Aruba’, ‘Anti-Boycott Aruba’.

After that we collected all the Facebook’s pages and groups containing the afore-mentioned keywords. In this way we have been able to map the general discourse about Aruba on Facebook.

As the Bubbles and the Tag Cloud show, we discovered that “Van Der Sloot” is the most prominent topic within the discourse about Aruba on Facebook, and that this discourse is mainly deployed in English - which is not the official language of Aruba.

Comment Frequency of Facebook users in anti boycot groups/pages

Comment Frequency of Facebook users in small boycot groups/pages

Comment Frequency of Facebook users in big boycot groups/pages

"All publicity is.. wait, he did what!?" Aruba in the Natalee Holloway Case

What image of Aruba emerges in relation to the 'Natalee Holloway' case on issue related facebook groups and -pages?

Method

1 step: we queried Natalee Holloway & Joran van der Sloot in Facebook and collected all groups and pages related to the issue

2 step: we analyzed titles of all groups and pages according to the number of members/ likes, language, attitude, stance and collective action

3 step: we zoomed into all groups and pages that have Aruba in the title - these were the ones organized around the boycott and anti-boycott of Aruba

4 step: we analyzed the actors posting on these groups/ pages along the categories sex, number of postings, cross-over postings within boycott and anti-boycott groups/ pages and across them (with DiscoverText)

5 step: we coded all wallposts and comments of these groups/ pages along the categories: positive, negative, case-related, not relevant (DiscoverText)

6 step: since we were interested in the image of Aruba that is performed through this case we focused on the positive and negative postings about Aruba and did an in-depth analysis along the categories (Discover Text):

- take action against aruba
- destroy aruba
- unsafe aruba
- failed aruba
- other neg.

- take action for aruba
- love aruba
- nice people
- pretty nature
- defend aruba
- other pos.

Findings

Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date WhoSorted ascending Comment
FB_Natalee_Joran_Pages.php.pdf.txttxt FB_Natalee_Joran_Pages.php.pdf.txt manage 113 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:48 AlessandroCaliandro FB Natalee Joran Pages
anti-boycott.jpgjpg anti-boycott.jpg manage 14 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:37 AstridMager  
boycott_aruba.jpgjpg boycott_aruba.jpg manage 8 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:37 AstridMager  
ANTI-BOYCOT_refined_coding_POSITIVE.jpgjpg ANTI-BOYCOT_refined_coding_POSITIVE.jpg manage 20 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:32 LasseTimmermann  
ArubaLanguage.PNGPNG ArubaLanguage.PNG manage 35 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:52 LasseTimmermann  
Aruba_Facebook_Pages.pdfpdf Aruba_Facebook_Pages.pdf manage 88 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:31 LasseTimmermann  
Aruba_Facebook_Pages.pngpng Aruba_Facebook_Pages.png manage 70 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:36 LasseTimmermann  
BOYCOT_group_distribution_metalevel.jpgjpg BOYCOT_group_distribution_metalevel.jpg manage 22 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:32 LasseTimmermann  
BOYCOT_group_refined_coding_NEGATIVE.jpgjpg BOYCOT_group_refined_coding_NEGATIVE.jpg manage 21 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:33 LasseTimmermann  
BOYCOT_refined_coding_POSITIVE.jpgjpg BOYCOT_refined_coding_POSITIVE.jpg manage 26 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:33 LasseTimmermann  
Comment_Frequency_Actors_Small_Boycot_Pages_Groups.pngpng Comment_Frequency_Actors_Small_Boycot_Pages_Groups.png manage 100 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:02 LasseTimmermann  
Comment_Frequency_Anti-Boycot_Groups_Pages.pngpng Comment_Frequency_Anti-Boycot_Groups_Pages.png manage 64 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:02 LasseTimmermann  
Comment_Frequency_Big_Boycot_Groups_Pages_7.pngpng Comment_Frequency_Big_Boycot_Groups_Pages_7.png manage 39 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:03 LasseTimmermann  
FB_Status_Sentiment_Aruba.pdfpdf FB_Status_Sentiment_Aruba.pdf manage 36 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:38 LasseTimmermann  
aruba_tweet_sentiments.pdfpdf aruba_tweet_sentiments.pdf manage 37 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:38 LasseTimmermann  
fab_status_sentiment_aruba.pngpng fab_status_sentiment_aruba.png manage 116 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:40 LasseTimmermann  
natalee_holloway.pngpng natalee_holloway.png manage 101 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:54 LasseTimmermann  
tweet_sentinment_aruba.pngpng tweet_sentinment_aruba.png manage 103 K 08 Jul 2011 - 13:40 LasseTimmermann  
Facebook_Aruba_pages_categories.pdfpdf Facebook_Aruba_pages_categories.pdf manage 229 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:17 MichaelStevenson  
Facebook_Aruba_pages_categories.pngpng Facebook_Aruba_pages_categories.png manage 207 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:21 MichaelStevenson  
Facebook_aruba_groups_categorized.pdfpdf Facebook_aruba_groups_categorized.pdf manage 239 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:16 MichaelStevenson  
Facebook_aruba_groups_categorized.pngpng Facebook_aruba_groups_categorized.png manage 243 K 08 Jul 2011 - 14:22 MichaelStevenson  
aruba_facebook.pngpng aruba_facebook.png manage 19 K 08 Jul 2011 - 09:42 MichaelStevenson  
Topic revision: r18 - 08 Jul 2011, MichaelStevenson
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Foswiki? Send feedback